As a Pennsylvania independent agent, I get a lot of questions from drivers in Milford, Honesdale, Dunmore and around the state about whether or not they should file an auto insurance claim for a particular accident. It seems that the prevailing logic is that claims make car insurance premiums go up every time. Perhaps now would be a good time to explain a little bit about how car insurance claims affect an auto insurance policy.
While it’s true that filing insurance claims can cause your premiums to go up, it does not necessarily have to happen in every case. When you file a claim, an independent agent like me will look at several factors before making any decisions about your policy.
One major factor we look at is the severity of the accident. More damage means more cost to repair, which means we will likely need to charge you higher premiums to get our money back. Fault is another important factor–if the accident is your fault, you are more likely to have premium increase.
Your driving history also affects how we interpret a claim. If you haven’t had an accident in 15 years, we’re more likely to let your premiums stay the same after a small or medium-sized accident. On the other hand, if you’re good for a major accident a week, we might even be forced to drop your policy.
In Pennsylvania, personal injury protection (PIP) insurance is mandatory and you should file a claim use it whenever you have medical bills related to an accident. Using PIP insurance cannot affect your premiums in any way in this state.
So whether you drive in Honesdale, Dunmore or Milford, a claim doesn’t necessarily mean a major change in your insurance premiums, but it can.